Judging Feedback Protocol
Members of the Toowoomba Photographic Society are expected to abide by the code of conduct spelt out in the Membership Info document on our website. In particular members must conduct themselves in a responsible and respectful manner towards fellow members and our guests. In particular we should be respectful at all times towards the judges invited to judge our competitions.
Judges are volunteers who have spent considerable time reviewing your images and preparing their critiques. Judging is a time consuming activity which is by its very nature quite subjective. There are many factors that a judge will take into account in scoring an image and no two judges will see a photo in the same way. As a consequence we may not always agree with the scores or comments given by a judge. But we have to accept that they are the judge and their decision is final.
The TPS Committee provides written feedback to every judge using the Photographic Society of Queensland judging feedback sheet. If you wish to congratulate or have particular concerns about a judging you should make these known in writing to the TPS Committee as soon as possible after the judging. This way constructive feedback can be provided to the judge – this will provide them with considered feedback from our club and keep our club in good standing.
by Graham Harris, March 11, 2019
TPS Club Meeting – 12th March 2019
Our next club meeting is at 7:00pm this coming Tuesday, 12th March 2019. There have been 135 images submitted by 49 club members for our March 2019 Aggregate Competition which will be judged this evening by commercial photographer, Carmel Hunn from Photos by Carmen, Sunshine Coast.
The Set Subject for this month is “Naked Tree/s”.
We look forward to catching up with you all this evening.
And don’t forget that entries for the April 2019 Competition are required by 12:00 midnight on the 12th March 2019 – the set subject for that month “Expressions”.
by Graham Harris, March 6, 2019
TPS Skills Night – 26 February 2019
Our next TPS Skills Night is on Tuesday, 26 February 2098 at 7:00pm. For this month the Image Challenge is “Tracks”. Please send up to five images for this Challenge, together with up to five images for the Field Day and five for the Favourites to be included in the Skills Night audio-visual to me at graham_harris@westnet.com.au by 6:00pm on Monday 25th February 2019.
by Graham Harris, February 24, 2019
Alice Black Award – February 2019 – “Harrow Homestead Front Room” by Allan Rosser
To perpetuate the memory of our late member Alice Black, the club has introduced the ‘Alice Black Memorial Trophy’ to be contested each year on a perpetual basis.
At each month’s Aggregate Competition the judge will select an image from all those entered as the monthly Alice Black Image – they will use their own criteria to select the image regardless of the score given. All images submitted in the Aggregate Competition have the potential to become a possible winner of the Trophy as there is no restriction on the grade of the entrant or the medium in which the image is presented.
For February 2019 the Alice Black has been awarded to Allan Rosser for his print image “Harrow Homestead Front Room” taken at our September 2018 Field Day with Stanthorpe Camera Club. This image was entered in the A Grade Print Field Day section.
Our judge, John North commented “Outstanding print quality, everything is very sharp.”
by Graham Harris, February 23, 2019
TPS Club Meeting – 12th February 2019
Our next club meeting is at 7:00pm this coming Tuesday, 12th February 2019. There have been 133 images submitted by club members for our February 2019 Aggregate Competition which will be judged this evening by John North.
The Set Subject for this month is “Coastal”.
We look forward to catching up with you all this evening.
And don’t forget that entries for the March 2019 Competition are required by 12:00 midnight on the 12th February 2018 – the set subject for that month “Naked tree/s”.
by Graham Harris, February 10, 2019
Photography Training Notes now available
The training notes from the fortnightly photography training sessions at Jilly’s Cafe are now available in the members area of our TPS website. They can be accessed by clicking on the Photography Training Notes link which will take you to the Training Notes page.
by Graham Harris, January 28, 2019
Alice Black Award – December 2018 – “Free as a bird” by Stewart Dorman
To perpetuate the memory of our late member Alice Black, the club has introduced the ‘Alice Black Memorial Trophy’ to be contested each year on a perpetual basis.
At each month’s Aggregate Competition the judge will select an image from all those entered as the monthly Alice Black Image – they will use their own criteria to select the image regardless of the score given. All images submitted in the Aggregate Competition have the potential to become a possible winner of the Trophy as there is no restriction on the grade of the entrant or the medium in which the image is presented.
For December 2018 the Alice Black has been awarded to Stewart Dorman for his digital image “Free as a bird” taken at our October 2018 Field Day shoot at Boggo Road Gaol. This image was entered in the B Grade Digital Field Day section.
Our judge, Brian Kenny commented “Good monochrome conversion. Great silhouette, with just enough detail retained in the shadows. Even for someone who doesn’t know it was taken at Boggo Rpad, this image and title work together well.”
by Graham Harris, December 11, 2018
TPS Skills Night – 27 November 2018
by Graham Harris, November 21, 2018
Alice Black Award – November 2018 – “A Wet Day in the Horse Yards” by John Stewart
To perpetuate the memory of our late member Alice Black, the club has introduced the ‘Alice Black Memorial Trophy’ to be contested each year on a perpetual basis.
At each month’s Aggregate Competition the judge will select an image from all those entered as the monthly Alice Black Image – they will use their own criteria to select the image regardless of the score given. All images submitted in the Aggregate Competition have the potential to become a possible winner of the Trophy as there is no restriction on the grade of the entrant or the medium in which the image is presented.
For November 2018 the Alice Black has been awarded to John Stewart for his print “A wet day in the horse yards”. This image was entered in the Salon Grade Mono Set Subject: “Motion” Print section.
Our judge, Allan Rosser commented “Well done, slow enough to show the drops dropping, but not slow enough for other things to blur. The progression of dark to light enhances the image.”
by Graham Harris, November 21, 2018
TPS Club Meeting – 13 November 2018
Our next club meeting is at 7:00pm this coming Tuesday, 13th November 2018. There have been 131 images submitted by 46 club members for our November 2018 Aggregate Competition which will be judged this evening by Allen Rosser.
The Set Subject for this month is “Motion”.
We look forward to catching up with you all this evening.
And don’t forget that entries for the December 2018 Competition are required by 12:00 midnight on the 13th November 2018 – the set subject for this month is “Fairs, Shows, Markets”.
by Graham Harris, November 11, 2018
